To be as fair as possible, I will say that if someone has feet that run a bit narrow, this might be an excellent choice. Also, if someone does not need as much orthotic support. I have six pairs of Orthaheels and love them. This shoe fit much tighter and shorter than the other Orthaheels, the toebox did not have enough room, and the binding that goes around the top cut into my foot. However, the most disappointing factor was that the support that I have found in all my other Orthaheels was not as pronounced. That said, they are very cute shoes, and I think someone else who has a more narrow foot or who doesn't require a great deal of support might fall in love with them. They are made as well as my other Orthaheels, of high quality materials. I will continue to watch for a Mary Jane that works better for me. That said, I do very much love the Melissa style. I am giving this four stars because I really do think others might like it, and I don't want to discourage them.
